I found this at my library and though I should take a look. It was just going to be a brief review, but I’ve already reviewed the actual story when I looked at all the Famous Five Short Stories.

My plan then became comparing it to an earlier copy of the story – the one published in the 1997 Red Fox paperback collection. I couldn’t tell just by the quick flick through it whether or not it had been significantly changed, I’m not nearly as familiar with the story as I am the main books.

For background the story was originally published in The Princess Gift Book for Girls in 1960, though it’s labelled as the 1961 book as it was an annual. I don’t have this – but I have actually just ordered a copy – so I’ve never seen the original text or the illustrations.
Because of that I’m not going to do a word for word comparison like I have for other books (but maybe I will when the annual arrives.) I don’t actually know if the Red Fox edition is a word-for-word reprinting of the earlier stories but it strikes me now that I could have checked that for some of the stories already. That’s another maybe for future posts, then.
Colour Short Stories
Until now I didn’t actually know how many of these there are as I haven’t been keeping track. Turns out that there are the original 8 short stories and I’ve just found book #22 is to be released in 2027, with all the rest of these being original stories like The Painting Puzzle and The Library Mystery. I assume all the additional titles are by Sufiya Ahmed.
Good Old Timmy!
I didn’t exactly heap praises on this story when I reviewed it before –
On the beach the Five meet Oliver, Uncle Quentin’s scientist friend’s son, and then witness his kidnap by two nasty men who’ve been hanging round for a few days. The kidnappers leave their dog to run after the car, so Timmy is able to follow them. They find Oliver in the town, but they’ve got to deal with the men’s dog before they can rescue him.
Another very short tale, which does feel a touch rushed and contrived. Oliver’s father had letter that morning threatening to kidnap his son if he didn’t give up some information, and then he let his small-for-his-age 10 year old go to the beach alone. The men then kidnap him, right in front of a bunch of witnesses, and don’t even put their dog in the car when they go. Conveniently, the men are out when the Five find Oliver and their only obstacle (the dog) is subdued after a very brief scary moment.
A bit disappointing, over all, but kids will probably still enjoy it. This was written late on Blyton’s career, about the time her books started to decline in quality (think Five Are Together Again, The Mystery of Banshee Towers and The Hidey-Hole) so perhaps this story is another example of that. It’s just lacking something for me. There are some silly or contrived moments in the novels, but perhaps just not so many in so few pages.
I’m pretty sure this will not be improved upon by reprinting it with colour illustrations and stupid different sized words.
In the Red Fox collection the story runs to 12 pages with a couple of small illustrations. The new edition has 80 pages to allow for the larger (and sometimes very large text) and a ton of full colour illustrations. It has also been split into seven chapters. And yes – it has been updated. Various wordings are changed to modernise it.
Re-reading has definitely not improved my opinion of the story. It’s still weak and silly. Why do the men not take their dog with them? Why do they kidnap a boy, put him in a shed with a dog then both go to get petrol?
The illustrations this time are by Jamie Littler who I’m assuming is the original illustrator for the series – and the one who set the children’s appearances for the other illustrators to copy. Side note: why is Aunt Fanny giving them a picnic lunch that looks like bags of rubbish for the bin?

The illustrations don’t really help the story. They have the two men on the beach wearing full suits and ear pieces, standing right behind Oliver as if they are his bodyguards. Could anything be any more suspicious and obvious on a beach?

Then there’s this impossible cliff that looks like something out of The Grinch or The Nightmare before Christmas.

The illustrations also show them putting clothes back on over their swimming things, which is not reflected in the text (though actually makes sense!). However, the four are all shown at various points of climbing the cliff and then Timmy starting to follow the trail and none of them have the bag of clothes. It appears a couple of pages later with George carrying it.

Like the two other titles I’ve reviewed this is littered with words in a larger font, whether or not it makes sense to highlight these words. Various words which are italicised in the Red Fox copy are mostly NOT highlighted in the new copy. There are also several phrases put in wobbly writing to suggest fear. Honestly it’s just annoying and makes them so hard to read aloud because you immediately want to raise your voice or otherwise emphasise these words and phrases and you’d be going up and down all the time.

